We talk about putting children at the centre of family justice. But what does meaningful participation really look like, and are we investing equally in ensuring every child has a voice?
The President of the Family Division, Sir Stephen Cobb, has proposed that 2027 should be recognised as the Year of Children’s Participation.
His recent speech to the West Midlands Law Society is an important contribution to the ongoing conversation about how children experience family justice and, more importantly, how we ensure their voices are heard in decisions that shape their lives.
One observation particularly resonated with me:
80,000 children involved in family court proceedings are not simply 80,000 cases. They are 80,000 childhoods unfolding in real time.
This is a powerful reminder of why we do this work.
The development of the Child Focused Court model and the move towards a more child-centred approach in private law proceedings have prompted considerable discussion.
These developments are welcome because they offer an opportunity to understand children’s lived experiences, hear their perspectives earlier and ensure that decisions are informed by their circumstances. That is an approach we should all support.
However, I believe that conversation must give equal attention to meaningful participation for children in public law proceedings.
What about children in public law proceedings? The public law perspective
The President’s speech identifies more than 63,000 children involved in private law proceedings and more than 19,000 involved in public law proceedings.
These are children whose lives are often being shaped by decisions about their safety, their family relationships, their care arrangements and their long-term future.
As someone who predominantly represents children in public law proceedings, I see first-hand how important participation is.
Children may have experienced significant trauma, neglect, physical or sexual abuse, instability and disrupted relationships. Some are very young. Others are teenagers with firmly held views about what they want for their future.
They are not a homogenous group, and neither should our approach to their participation be.
Having representation does not automatically mean that a child feels involved in proceedings. Public law proceedings have established structures, including children’s guardians and solicitors representing children, but a child may still not understand what is happening or believe that their voice has made a difference.
We need to be careful not to confuse procedural representation with meaningful participation.
The role of the directly instructed solicitor
One area I believe deserves much greater attention is the role of the solicitor directly instructed by a child or young person.
There needs to be greater understanding across professional networks about when a child has the capacity to instruct their own solicitor, how that assessment is approached and what should happen when a young person exercises that right.
Are social work teams sufficiently trained in this area? Are there clear protocols to ensure that a directly instructed solicitor is recognised and appropriately included in the wider professional network?
Too often, a solicitor directly instructed by a child can find themselves left out of the loop.
This is a missed opportunity.
A solicitor instructed directly by a young person can help them understand proceedings, communicate their wishes and feelings and engage with decisions about their own life. Their contribution is therefore not simply a matter of attending meetings or receiving updates as another professional.
There must, of course, be appropriate respect for the solicitor-client relationship, confidentiality and the young person’s instructions. Within those boundaries, constructive professional relationships and appropriate communication can support the young person’s participation.
We should be asking how we can work better together, not allowing professional boundaries to become barriers to participation.
Participation requires flexibility, time and trust
I often think about what meaningful participation would look like in my own day-to-day practice.
It can mean evenings spent speaking with young people around their school commitments. Not because it is convenient for the professional timetable, but because that is when it works for the young person.
It means spending time building rapport, having conversations, understanding their experiences and finding out what they actually want the court and the other parties to know about them. Sometimes it takes several conversations before a young person feels comfortable enough to talk openly.
Sometimes it means changing the way we communicate, finding different ways to explain complex legal processes or simply allowing a conversation to develop without the pressure of having to achieve something within a set appointment.
These conversations are not necessarily visible in a court bundle or reflected in a case management order. But they can be fundamental to ensuring that a young person feels represented and involved.
Participation cannot be measured solely by whether a child has been seen, spoken to or asked for their views. It is about whether they have had a genuine opportunity to communicate in a way that works for them.
Moving beyond tokenism
The President refers to Professor Laura Lundy’s model of participation, which identifies four essential elements:
- Space: Children must have safe opportunities to express their views.
- Voice: They must be supported to communicate those views.
- Audience: Somebody must be willing to listen and take them seriously.
- Influence: Their views must be given proper consideration and there must be evidence of how they have informed decision-making.
I think the final element is particularly important.
Children do not necessarily expect to get the outcome they want. Nor should we transfer responsibility for adult decisions onto them.
But they should be able to understand that their views have been heard, considered and taken seriously.
If a child has expressed a clear wish to return home, for example, and the court ultimately decides that this cannot safely happen, meaningful participation includes helping that child understand why.
If we make decisions about children’s lives without ensuring they understand those decisions, have we really enabled them to participate fully?
The feedback loop is just as important as the opportunity to speak.
What needs to change?
If 2027 is genuinely going to be the Year of Children’s Participation, I would like to see the ambition translate into practical changes across the whole family justice system.
There are several areas where I believe we should be focusing our attention.
- Better training and understanding
We need investment in training for social workers, solicitors, Guardians and other professionals so that they can support children’s participation, communicate in ways that work for each child and understand capacity to instruct their own solicitor.
- Clearer protocols for directly instructed solicitors
We need clearer protocols that establish a consistent understanding of the role of a child’s directly instructed solicitor. Those protocols should set out appropriate arrangements for communication and professional engagement, with recognition of the solicitor-client relationship.
- Investment in public law proceedings
The ambition for a child-centred family justice system cannot be confined to private law reform. For children in care proceedings, we need to understand what additional resources are being made available to turn that ambition into meaningful opportunities to participate.
- Flexibility in professional practice
Participation needs to be built around the individual child. Their age, maturity, education, communication needs, experiences and circumstances should inform how we engage with them.
- Measuring meaningful participation
We should measure meaningful participation by asking children whether they feel heard, understand the process and believe their views have been considered. Recording how many children have been spoken to or how many meetings have taken place is not enough.
- Closing the feedback loop
Children should receive appropriate explanations of decisions affecting them. They should understand what has happened, why decisions have been made and what comes next.
The President has also highlighted the lack of national data around children’s participation. If we value participation, we should be measuring it, monitoring it and being transparent about where improvements are needed.
A responsibility we all share
I welcome the President’s ambition for 2027. His speech provides an important opportunity to challenge established professional cultures and consider whether we are genuinely doing enough to involve children in decisions affecting their lives.
But we must be careful that the conversation does not become solely about the introduction of new court models or changes to private law processes.
Children involved in public law proceedings deserve the same commitment to participation, investment and innovation.
We have spent years talking about putting children at the centre of family justice. The challenge now is to demonstrate what that means in practice.
We need to move away from measuring participation by the number of conversations, meetings or statements completed.
The real measure should be whether a child understands the process, feels able to express themselves, knows somebody has listened and can see that their views have been given proper consideration.
Participation is not a box to tick. It is a responsibility we all share.
Children should not have to wait for a new court model, a pilot or a reform programme to have their voices heard.
Their lives are happening now.
And if 2027 is to be the Year of Children’s Participation, let’s make sure that means every child, in every part of the family justice system: by changing how we listen, how we work together and how we explain the decisions that shape children’s lives.
About the author
Stacey is a solicitor at Cygnet Law, specialising in family and children’s law. She has over 11 years’ experience as a solicitor and has been a member of The Law Society’s Children Panel since 2023, representing parents, kinship carers, grandparents and children in complex legal matters.
Stacey is passionate about making legal services more accessible and inclusive. She has a particular interest in neurodiversity and improving the experiences of people who may face barriers when accessing legal advice, as well as advocating for LGBT+ families and survivors of domestic abuse.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of Today’s Family Lawyer.















