The entrance to the Royal Courts of Justice
Appeal court judges overturned the earlier decision. Photograph: Shutterstock

The Court of Appeal has granted a mother permission to oppose an adoption order, overturning a decision from the family court at Brighton.

In G (A Child: Leave to Oppose Adoption), the appeal court considered whether the mother of a four-year-old girl, G, should be granted leave to oppose an adoption order, after she was refused permission by Honour Judge Levey in August.

In April 2024, when D was around 21 months old, care proceedings began, and she was placed in foster care. She hasn’t lived with her mother for two years, and they were last in contact a year ago. 

The mother, who is now 24, has a history of addiction and is a victim of abuse. At a final hearing of the local authority’s application at Brighton family court in March 2025, the court heard of the mother’s drinking and drug use and a series of assaults of one kind or another on her by three partners, one being D’s father, in the previous two years. A serious incident in September 2023 had led to the mother being convicted of assaulting an emergency worker in D’s presence.

On 13 March 2025, the judge described the mother as a vulnerable young woman, who had had “a terrible childhood” involving serious sexual, physical and emotional abuse. He described her as “dignified and disarmingly candid” and said he “had no doubt of her commitment to the rehabilitation process for D’s sake as well as for her own”.

The child D was placed with a prospective adopter in October 2025, and in January 2026, an adoption application was issued.

The mother sought permission to oppose the making of an adoption order, supported by an initial statement. In June, the mother was directed by the court to file a further statement the reasons why she considered the granting of permission to oppose the adoption order was in D’s best interests.

The local authority was directed to file a reply covering a number of specified matters, and requiring a welfare checklist analysis.

In the mother’s statement of 24 July 2026, she offered evidence of a change of circumstances since March 2025, including having been free from drugs and alcohol since August 2025, even following the death of both of her parents in January.

She showed she has completed psychotherapy, found stable accommodation, ended her abusive relationship and obtained a restraining order against her former partner, who went to prison for assaulting her.

The mother started a new relationship in August 2025, which she described as “stable and supportive”.  She has been living with her new partner since March 2026, and the couple have a baby son, R, who was born in May. 

R is the subject of a Child Protection Plan, but no proceedings have been taken in respect of him.

The mother exhibited a number of documents in which professionals corroborated her account.

The mother said in her statement: “I feel that D should be given the chance to live with her birth family and to have a relationship with her brother. I have thought a lot about how this may cause some disruption to D, given how she may have settled into the prospective adopter’s care, but I feel that it would cause her less harm to have this disruption of a return to my care than to face a life of questioning why she was adopted.”

In August 2026, the local authority accepted that there had been a change in the mother’s circumstances, describing her abstinence as a significant achievement. It also accepted that her current relationship was of a very different character to previous relationships. However, there remained uncertainty about the long-term stability of those changes and it was the local authority’s view that they were not of a degree sufficient to re-open consideration of the issue of D’s adoption.

A statement was filed by D’s prospective adopter expressing her commitment to D and giving “a rich portrait” of her present life.

Having received written and oral submissions from counsel on 14 August 2026, the judge reserved his decision, and two weeks later, he handed down a 19-page judgment.

Judge Levey said: “Standing back and considering all the circumstances, I am not persuaded that the mother’s prospects of successfully resisting the adoption application are sufficiently strong to justify the grant of leave. The changes that have occurred are positive, but they remain relatively recent and insufficiently tested. 

“There remains uncertainty as to whether those changes have become embedded and whether they would endure if the demands of caring for D were added to the household. The risk of destabilisation is one which cannot properly be ignored.”

The adoption hearing was listed for 25 September 2026. On 18 September 2026, the mother sought permission to appeal on the grounds that the judge was wrong to determine that her prospects of opposing an adoption order were not “sufficiently strong” by failing to properly weigh her changed circumstances.

Her case also argued the judge placed improper weight on gaps in the evidence to determine the merits of the Mother’s application at a permission stage, and that the judge was wrong to say that it was not in D’s welfare interest to grant the mother permission to oppose the adoption order.

The appeal was put before Lord Justice Peter Jackson, Lord Justice Newey and Lady Justice May at the Royal Courts of Justice, who approved the mother’s application to oppose the adoption order.

The appeal judges made it clear that the question to be answered was whether or not it was in the child’s interests for there to be an opposed adoption hearing, and not whether it is in the child’s interests to be adopted. 

Judge Jackson remarked: “The decision is not a decision about adoption but a decision about the management of an adoption application.”

In a judgment handed down remotely on 11 November 2026, the judges said: “In this case, [judge Levey] acknowledged that the decision was one of some difficulty and he paid deep attention to it, including by reserving judgment and giving extensive reasons. Indeed, the very degree of care that he took gives some indication that the mother had put forward a solid case for the court’s consideration. As it was, his conclusion amounted to a judgement that her case would not succeed, when the question at that stage of the analysis was different and less demanding.”

The judgment, written by Judge Jackson and agreed by Justices Newey and May, concluded: “I would allow the appeal, grant the mother leave to oppose the making of an adoption order, and remit the proceedings for an early case management hearing before a judge nominated by the Family Presiding Judge. In doing so, I express no view whatever about the outcome of the adoption application, which will now be determined by the Family Court on the basis of all the evidence.”

Want to have your say? Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read more stories

Join nearly 3,000 other family practitioners - Check back daily for all the latest news, views, insights and best practice and sign up to our e-newsletter to receive our weekly round up every Thursday morning. 

You’ll receive the latest updates, analysis, and best practice straight to your inbox.

Features

https://www.bridgingthegap2026.co.uk/
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.