Houses of Parliament
Image: Shutterstock

Access to justice over-reliant on ‘patchwork’ of providers with early advice ‘insecure and under-resourced’

An NHS 111-style service to triage legal issues is amongst the recommendations of the Justice Committee in a newly published report on how consumers access legal services. 

The House of Commons select committee published Access to Justice: Access to Legal Services this week to consider the “wider system through which people recognise legal problems, obtain information and advice, navigate legal and court services, and secure the practical means to enforce their rights.”

The report follows the committee’s urgent call for intervention into Legal Aid which was published in July 2026.

The report outlines how 66% of adults in England and Wales face at least one significant legal problem each year, while 32% of people experienced an unmet legal need between 2019 and 2023; but consumer understanding of legal rights is weak and “rights have little practical value if people cannot identify, understand or enforce them” said the report.

“The same reasoning that supports preventative investment in the NHS should apply to legal support services” the report goes on to say, suggesting there is currently an overreliance on “a patchwork of legal aid, local authority commissioning, charitable grants, pro bono work and short-term government programmes. The justice system should not rely on courts, tribunals and crisis intervention while allowing the early advice services capable of preventing escalation to remain insecure and under-resourced.”

The NHS 111-style service is one of four recommendations the committee makes.

In addressing the need for additional funding for legal services, particularly Legal Aid courts or other justice services, the report acknowledges the proposed Interest on Lawyers’ Client Accounts (ILCA) scheme could provide “substantial additional funding”, but warns its design should not remove interest from firms that rely upon it to maintain legal aid or other low-cost services.

The warnings echo the view of the Law Society said it agrees with the concerns of the committee which it set out in its response to the Ministry of Justice consultation.

Law Society president Brett Dixon he doubted a workable scheme could be devised: “The scheme cannot and should not proceed. The proposal is flawed, sets a damaging precedent and conflicts with wider government commitments on growth. It is unlikely to generate more than a tiny fraction of the sums needed to meaningfully improve the justice system, and it is unlikely to be a significant or reliable new source of revenue. It is simply not fit for purpose.”

The committee suggest any scheme should be “independently administered, use transparent grant-making criteria, maintain reserves to manage volatility, and include safeguards such as appropriate exemptions for legal aid providers and other financially vulnerable firms.”

Dormant client balances, undistributed collective action sums, recovered criminal assets and carefully targeted contributions from litigation funding profits and high-value litigation are all options for additional funding the reports goes on to suggest.

The committee calls for a review of regulation, criticising a lack of transparency over consumer understanding of unregulated and regulated legal services and providers, and simplifying the structure of regulation. The report specifically states “this could be through the establishment of a single legal services regulator.”

“There must be greater emphasis on regulated activities and risks, clearer consumer information and redress, and effective oversight of new digital and AI-assisted services” adds the report with Chair of the Justice Committee and Labour MP Catherine Atkinson saying “legal advice has been provided through a disjointed system, with responsibility spread across government departments, councils, charities and regulators. The Ministry of Justice should take the lead in coordinating services, checking whether they can meet demand and acting where people are going without help.”

Recent firm failures, the report notes, have also exposed serious weaknesses in supervision and damaged consumer confidence. MPs recommended there must be greater emphasis on regulated activities and risks, clearer consumer information and redress, and effective oversight of new digital and AI-assisted services.

The final recommendation concerns the provision of litigation funding calling for “immediate legislation to reverse the effects of the PACCAR judgment.” Reform of the civil litigation funding landscape should include an extension of qualified one-way costs shifting, a review of fixed recoverable costs, statutory regulation of third-party litigation funding and protection of opt-out collective actions.

The growth of third party litigation, up ten-fold since 2011 according the report has seen private methods of funding assume greater importance as public funding has been reduced. In Sweden, for example, before-the-event legal expenses insurance is held by 95% of households; in the UK the figure is 8%. Proportionate and effective regulation is needed concludes the report.

Having provided written and oral evidence to the inquiry Legal Services Board Chair, Monisha Shah and CEO, Richard Orpin responded to the report saying: “This report highlights the many complex challenges and the urgent need to improve access to justice. We welcome the Committee’s support for our focus on core regulatory priorities. I also note its concerns that system leadership on innovation and legal needs research are useful and important contributions which must not be lost.

“I have written to the Committee setting out our response to the Public Bodies Review and how we are refocusing our activity on areas of greatest risk to consumers. Technology and innovation remain part of that focus. We are also strengthening consumer protection and redress through our oversight of, and collaboration with, frontline regulators and the Office for Legal Complaints.

“We have set expectations for clearer information on the price and quality of legal services, and requirements to improve the handling of complaints. We are holding regulators to account for putting these changes into practice and showing what difference they make for consumers.

“Being able to choose and use legal services helps people exercise their rights. That is fundamental to a fair society. We will play our part to improve the effectiveness of the legal services framework so that it better serves the public interest, protects consumers, and supports access to justice.”

Law Society president Brett Dixon added: ““The Committee sets out important recommendations, which go some way to improving signposting towards legal services, after chronic underfunding from successive governments,” said Law Society president, Brett Dixon.

“Civil legal aid is a vital public service that supports our communities and reduces the strain on other services.

“As the report makes clear, the legal sector relies on a patchwork of legal aid, pro bono work, charitable grants and short-term government programmes. A National Legal Service is a helpful addition to signposting people to legal advice but is not a substitute for a sustainably funded network of local legal providers.

“The Law Society’s research* has found that millions are living without access to legal aid in England and Wales.

“The proposal for an AI-assisted legal support platform and public legal information repository is similar to the Solutions Explorer put forward in the Law Society’s 21st Century Justice report.

“A triage tool would act as a trusted public online one-stop shop for assessing legal issues and signposting to support. However, this triage must be complimented by robust face to face provision. NHS 111 could not exist without GP and hospital services. Likewise, a network of local legal aid provision is essential.

“If our government truly believes in acting for the common good, they must guarantee that all of us – no matter where we live or how much money we have – have what we need to access justice.”

 

Access to Justice: Access to Legal Services

See all related topics:

Want to have your say? Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read more stories

Join nearly 3,000 other family practitioners - Check back daily for all the latest news, views, insights and best practice and sign up to our e-newsletter to receive our weekly round up every Thursday morning. 

You’ll receive the latest updates, analysis, and best practice straight to your inbox.

Features

https://www.bridgingthegap2026.co.uk/
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.